In this powerful documentary, Brazilian filmmaker Petra Costa intertwines her own family history with the democratic journey of her home country. As she says herself, Costa and her country’s democracy are of the same age. This is not the only reason why she was uniquely positioned to make a film like this: her parents were left-wing activists in the 1970s, who went to jail for their beliefs, while her grandparents were part of the ruling class have made Brazil’s strong-man politics and right-wing backlash possible. Her mother was held at the same prison that ex-president Dilma Rousseff (2011-2016) was sent to. Costa tells the story of Rousseff’s demise as well as that of Luiz Inácio da Silva (2003-2011) aka Lula, whose future remains up in the air. The Edge of Democracy is thus a gripping and urgent warning that democracy in the world’s sixth most populous country is under attack. In content and form, Costa is obviously opinionated, but she makes a strong point.
As a Brazilian myself and having watched this documentary, I can confirm it's quite an impressive piece of work. Although a little biased sometimes, it shows quite precisely what happens in Brazil at the moment and it can be perfectly replicated to a big number of democracies around the world: center-left governments being ousted from power due to illegal and unethical maneuvers done by growing alt-right conservative parties sponsored by powerful groups and controlling a vast net of fake news. If you like politics you'll surely appreciate it. 3 people liked this review.
Ok. This is the first non-angry, fair and balanced comment about this documentary here. Listen to this guy. 2 people liked this review.
It's more a narrative of the director's life journey and her personal relationship to what's happening than a documentary really. While it shows , yes and indeed, a lot of what is happening, it's not revolutionary. It doesn't show anything new or thought-provoking. The director, who is also narrating, rarely analyses her own footage, she doesn't bring historians, political scientists, economists, journalists, people who think differently than her or... somebody else to add up her melancholic descriptions. I got chills because every time you remember how politics deviated from what it was supposed to be, you get this dark feeling on your chest, the same one I get when I get immersed on the news or study history. This said-documentary just echoes everything the Left has been saying and annoys the Right, so it does nothing else than political polarization, the same one she showed during her footage. Felt like I wasted my time. If I wanted to watch what is already written everywhere on the news, then I would just have read the news. 10 people liked this review.
Its a bad documentary trying to make people believe in this corrupt people that once ruled the country! Dont believe their lies!!! 0 people liked this review.
The Edge of Democracy consolidates a lying narrative and even sanctifies a corrupt leader. The film shows a whole generation corrupted by unscrupulous parents, teachers and leaders, led to believe in the superiority of the collective over the individual, the material over the spiritual, equality about a difference, a generation for which reality has to adapt to a story told by a voice narrator as childish as their perception of the world so that their dreams and frustrations can fit into that reality.
A truly lost generation. -4 people liked this review.
This a documentry for those who are interested in politics and know little more about Brazil from an alternate angle. -2 people liked this review.