Earth Mama (2023) | agoodmovietowatch
Back
Movie

Earth Mama 2023

A searingly emotional blend of social and magical realism from a one-to-watch director

Our Take (by Farah Cheded)

Based on the documentary short she helmed with actor Taylor Russell, Savannah Leaf’s Earth Mama is an intimate, unabashedly political, and decisively non-judgmental look at one mother’s determined attempts to regain custody of her two children. Gia (Tia Nomore) is struggling to work enough hours at her part-time photo studio job to pay for the home she needs before she can be reunited with her kids — struggling because the state also requires her to attend classes on topics like addiction recovery, which are eating into her time. What’s more, Gia is also heavily pregnant, and her looming due date sets a clock ticking on her efforts to satisfy her caseworker and decide what’s best for her new baby. 

There’s a depressingly cyclical nature to all this heartbreak, as testified to by the real people who sometimes pierce the drama to share their own experiences of the system Gia is navigating. Their contributions — along with Nomore’s lived-in performance and Leaf’s assured touch — deepen the urgency and emotion of the movie, which is as much a commentary on the dehumanizing bureaucracy of the social care system as it is Gia’s own particular story.

Notable Critics

"Leaf dramatizes Gia’s conflicts in scenes of trenchant dialogue... which give voice to the multigenerational traumas of Black families torn apart for political purposes."

— Richard Brody

"The first insanely good entry into what we can hope will be a long and winding career behind the camera."

— David Jenkins

Synopsis

A pregnant single mother, with two children in foster care, embraces her Bay Area community as she fights to reclaim her family.

More about it

What happens

A pregnant single mother navigates a dehumanizing bureaucratic system as she fights for custody of her two children.

What sets it apart

Earth Mama’s subject matter and storytelling steer it into the realm of social realism, but that genre rarely looks like it does here. Cinematographer Jody Lee Lipes shoots all this raw emotion on gorgeous, grainy 16mm, but the film sometimes drifts into outright dreamlike interludes inspired by the natural environment of its Bay Area setting: redwood forests and lapping ocean waves. For Gia, the magical realist excursions she embarks on are a balm to all the hardship she experiences — they’re an escape. What’s more, these scenes of her communing with nature also affirm the near-sacredness of the role she's fighting so hard to protect: that of a mother.

TL;DR

A breakout for everyone involved, especially first-time feature director Savanah Leaf and acting newcomer Tia Nomore.

Awards

BAFTA

1 win

Won: Outstanding Debut by a British Writer, Director or Producer

Spirit Awards

2 nominations

Nominated: Best Breakthrough PerformanceNominated: Best First Feature

Sundance

1 nomination

Nominated: Official Selection

Nat. Board of Review

1 win

Won: Top 10 Independent Films

Comments

Add your review

Your email address will not be published.*

About the author

Farah Cheded

Farah Cheded

Farah Cheded is a UK-based curator at A Good Movie to Watch and a Rotten Tomatoes-approved freelance critic whose work has been published at outlets including The Playlist, Paste Magazine, and Film School Rejects. She lives in fear of the day she runs out of 'Columbo' episodes to watch.