She's Gotta Have It (1986)

She's Gotta Have It (1986)

Spike Lee’s electric, jazz-like confrontation of sexual politics announced the indisputable arrival of a new filmmaking icon

The Very Best

8.0

Movie

United States of America
English
Comedy, Romance
1986
SPIKE LEE
Bill Lee, Cheryl Burr, Eric Payne
84 min

TLDR

It says something that “We let her create a three-headed, six-armed, six-legged, three-penised monster” isn’t even the craziest line in this.

What it's about

Nola Darling’s three lovers — an egotistical model (John Canada Terrell), boyish smooth-talker (Spike Lee), and the suave yet controlling Jamie (Tommy Redmond Hicks) — want her to choose between them, but what if there’s another option: not choosing at all?

The take

Spike Lee burst onto the filmmaking scene with this, his groundbreaking debut feature. Low in budget but high in confidence, She’s Gotta Have It fizzes with unadulterated energy and style, from its kaleidoscopic opening montage of stills depicting life in Brooklyn (where the film is set) to the joyous direct addresses of its credits sequence.

The film helped to kick off the independent movie movement in the US, and it’s not hard to see why: Lee and his collaborators (including members of his own family) do so much with so little here. Along with its visual and formal inventiveness — including ample fourth wall breaks and cinematographer Ernest Dickerson’s momentary, audacious switch from black-and-white to vibrant color — She’s Gotta Have It also broke new ground with Nola (Tracy Camilla Johns), the young, Black, unapologetically polyamorous artist whom the film’s forthright exploration of sexuality and feminism is centered on. Lee has since expressed regret about one scene in the film — an ill-judged moment that unavoidably dilutes some of its brilliance — but this aside, She’s Gotta Have It stands overall as a radical, exuberant, and impressively assertive lightning bolt of an entry into the medium that Lee changed forever.

What stands out

Though the narrative is, admittedly, imperfect, Lee’s debut largely still feels as fresh as it must have on its original release. Its riotously experimental flourishes of style and gleeful embrace of its own DIY roughness are an inadvertent reminder of how risk-averse the vast bulk of cinema has sadly been since Lee’s debut. Its enduring freshness is also mirrored in large part by Nola’s liberated sexuality and the film’s frank recognition of the limiting influence of the fragile men in her life — complexity that would be impressive in a fourth or fifth feature, let alone a first.

Comments

Add a comment

Your name

Your comment

UP NEXT 

UP NEXT 

UP NEXT 

Hitman Hart: Wrestling With Shadows (1998)

A documentary capturing one of the most important transition periods in WWF, through the eyes of Canadian wrestling hero Bret Hart

8.5

Beyond the Mat (1999)

The quintessential ‘90s pro wrestling documentary that shows that the top of the mountain carries more insanity than glory

8.0

Secret Sunshine (2007)

A grieving woman deals with the worst of fates in this challenging, disquieting riverside drama

7.6

Infamous (2006)

A slightly embellished, often compared, retelling that depicts the classic novelist’s larger-than-life spirit

7.0

La Chimera (2023)

A dreamy, bewitching film that ponders on ideas of lostness and longing

8.0

Forgotten Love (2023)

The stunning third take of the classic Polish pre-war melodrama

7.7

Chinese Odyssey 2002 (2002)

An absurd, ridiculous parody of classic Chinese dramas that comes with a sweet twist

7.5

System Crasher (2019)

A tale of trauma and one of the most talked about movies on Netflix in 2020.

9.0

Housekeeping for Beginners (2024)

At once understated and powerful, this Macedonian drama shines a necessary light on the complexity of found families

7.8

Trick (1999)

A witty and refreshing comedy-of-errors depicting the gay community in the big city

7.4

Curated by humans, not algorithms.

agmtw logo

© 2024 agoodmovietowatch, all rights reserved.