When a mix-up in the school pick-up line turns out to be a kidnapping, it’s the beginning of the nightmare for the whole Irvine family. Except, as this crime thriller investigates the case, most side-eye and imply that it’s All Her Fault. The blame rests on the mothers’ shoulders, but mainly because the burden of the mental load and all the logistics rest on the shoulders of Marissa Irvine and Jenny Kaminski for their respective families. While the crime itself unfolds to somewhat melodramatic motives, the series ultimately works because of the incredible performances. Sarah Snook and Dakota Fanning portray a compelling bond formed by the empathy they both grant each other, when the rest of the world wouldn’t.