I Killed My Mother (2009) | agoodmovietowatch

100% human-curated. No AI, no algorithms.

I Killed My Mother 7.0 2009 Movie

I Killed My Mother

Dir. Xavier Dolan · Canada · French

An unflinchingly honest family drama from a young filmmaker, authentic down to its imperfections

Our take by Bronte Lacsamana

Xavier Dolan’s emotionally charged directorial debut centers on the complex relationship between 16-year-old Hubert and his mother, brought to life by Dolan himself and Anne Dorval, respectively. The film paints an authentic and all-too-familiar picture of two people who love each other yet clash in similarly self-centered and stubborn ways.

The mother-and-son duo vacillate between love and hate in a screenplay full of drama. The cinematography, relying much on negative space, perfectly evokes a sense of disconnect and animosity. However, there is little subtlety to be found here, much like Hubert’s sexuality being embodied by a poster of River Phoenix displayed in his bedroom. The rawness and heightened telling of events indicate that this story is as fresh and unpolished as then 19-year-old Dolan’s own feelings about family dysfunction, particularly mommy issues. The heavy-handedness and moments of exaggeration in his quasi-autobiography are obvious, a fault of execution that one can attribute to lack of experience.

Still, the powerful visuals and dialogue hint at a vision of what more to expect in Dolan’s now-celebrated career. I Killed My Mother, by all accounts, fulfills its role as his promising directorial debut.

What happens

Hubert, a brash 17-year-old, is confused and torn by a love-hate relationship with his mother that consumes him more and more each day. After distressing ordeals and tragic episodes, Hubert will find his mother on the banks of Saint Lawrence river, where he grew up, and where a murder will be committed: the murder of childhood.

What the critics said

Notable Critics

"Dolan's vision, however distracted, remains strong ( ... ) As a writer, director, producer, and actor, he throws himself into the film's disjointed spaces, highlighting the ways in which multiple and contradictory states can be inhabited simultaneously"

— Genevieve Yue

"This just might be as close as we'll ever get to seeing "Catcher in the Rye" on the screen. Truly hilarious."

— Brandon Judell

Awards

Cannes

3 wins

Won: C.I.C.A.E. AwardWon: Regards Jeunes PrizeWon: SACD Prize (Directors' Fortnight)

César Awards

1 nom

Nominated: Best Foreign Film

Comments

Add your review

Your email address will not be published.*

About the author

Bronte Lacsamana

Brontë Lacsamana is a multimedia reporter for the business newspaper BusinessWorld, covering arts, culture, and entertainment from film and television to visual arts and music. She was selected for the 2024 QCinema Critics Lab.