agmtw logo
search
All the Light We Cannot See

All the Light We Cannot See

TV-MA

A stunning adaptation whose decent performances can’t hold up the novel’s striking prose

6.3

TV Show

United States of America
English
Drama
2023
Aria Mia Loberti, Hugh Laurie, Lars Eidinger

TLDR

As a book fan, it wasn’t bad, it just wasn’t AS GOOD as the novel.

What it's about

In the coastal town of Saint-Malo, in the 1940s, blind French teenager Marie-Laure reads old classics through a radio broadcast. German soldier Werner, forced to join the Nazis, secretly listens to the broadcast, despite army regulations. Their paths collide in occupied France, as they try to survive the war.

The take

With the source material being a Pulitzer winning novel, All The Light We Cannot See had high expectations. Plenty of what made the novel great was its straightforward prose, as well as its back-and-forth timeline, where each scene is arranged not by chronological order, but by the thematic logic that informs the characters’ actions. The new Netflix adaptation keeps the novel’s structure, however, the novel’s poetry is lost as the metaphors are shortened to its most cliché versions, and the showrunners couldn’t trust that the viewers would acknowledge the novel’s subtleties. While the cast does what it can, the show just feels like a missed opportunity to tell an excellent story.

What stands out

All The Light We Cannot See has its flaws as an adaptation, as plenty of the intricacies in the original novel has been lost from the show’s 4-hour runtime. However, the show did a great job in its casting, especially with its two leads. German actor Louis Hofmann was great as Werner Pfennig, the reluctant German teenager whose technological skill dooms him to service in the Nazi forces. However, it’s newcomer Aria Mia Loberti that steals the show, even from acting veterans like Hugh Laurie and Mark Ruffalo. Like her character Marie-Laure, she is legally blind, but she also has the same wide-eyed innocence that makes her hope feel believable.

Comments

Add a comment

Your name

Your comment

UP NEXT 

UP NEXT 

UP NEXT 

Say Nothing

A powerful take on the Northern Ireland conflict that smartly shows all sides

8.5

Ethos

A level of attention to aesthetics usually reserved for the most elaborate films, mixed with a complex and relevant story, make this series from Turkey unmatched in its quality

9.9

Caliphate

A psychological thriller that provides insight on what drove so many young people to ISIS.

8.9

Occupied

Norway's most expensive show ever is a timely thrill ride with a grim geopolitical premise.

8.7

Interior Chinatown

A novel and daring action comedy that plays on Asian American stereotypes

7.5

Escape at Dannemora

Based on a true prison escape story, this slow-burn suspense thriller features once-in-a-lifetime performances by a star-studded cast

9.3

Unorthodox

A well-acted fact-based thriller about untangling the grip of a close-knit community

8.5

Wild Wild Country

Almost too outrageous to be true – this captivating true crime docuseries tells the unlikely story of an Indian cult in America

9.8

The Looming Tower

A well-written thriller miniseries about the rivalry between the CIA and the FBI and how they failed to prevent 9/11.

8.1

Dune: Prophecy

Two sisters shift the balance of power in this Dune prequel series

7.0

Curated by humans, not algorithms.

agmtw logo

© 2024 agoodmovietowatch, all rights reserved.