The presentation is high energy and aggressive (in a fun way), conveying both the competitive and communal nature of a barbecue cook-off show. But something about it is just anxiety triggering. Some challenges and time limits feel arbitrary, falling back on “well, it’s a challenge” to justify itself. The huge cash prize is a given, but it just feels more high stress than it needs to be, like grade schoolers trying to impress the principal. Of course, none of that is on the participants who are a joy to watch; and it’s fair to argue that over-dramatic flair is a staple of competition shows, but there are also many others that have utilized it much more pleasantly.

It’s definitely a show you can smell.