Smoke (1995) | agoodmovietowatch
Back
Movie

Smoke 1995

A gorgeous indie gem whose every note is worth inhaling

Our Take (by Farah Cheded)

Like a long, slow drag of a cigar, Smoke is a patient pleasure. Adam Holender’s leisurely lingering camera and the film’s relaxed editing allow us to savor the actors’ performances and the thoughtful script uninterrupted, trusting in their ability to captivate us. And captivate us is exactly what novelist Paul Auster’s screenplay and the film’s superlative ensemble do.

The film kicks off in Auggie Wren’s (Harvey Keitel) Brooklyn smoke shop, where myriad customers linger to chat and unexpected friendships form. The serendipitous network around which Smoke revolves unfurls gradually, like a curling wisp of smoke: Auggie’s patron Paul (William Hurt), a writer’s block-struck novelist grieving the violent death of his pregnant wife some years ago, has his life saved by Harold Perrineau’s Rashid, the estranged 17-year-old son of a struggling mechanic (Forest Whitaker). Ashley Judd and Stockard Channing also feature in Auggie’s portion of the film, one of its five loose vignettes (although the film flows much more fluidly than a chapterized structure suggests). Auster’s contemplative, dialogue-driven screenplay — along with the film’s unhurried editing and luxuriating cinematography — make Smoke a gorgeous example of the art of savoring, which is exactly what you want to do with this wonderful movie.

Synopsis

Writer Paul Benjamin is nearly hit by a bus when he leaves Auggie Wren's smoke shop. Stranger Rashid Cole saves his life, and soon middle-aged Paul tells homeless Rashid that he wouldn't mind a short-term housemate. Still grieving over his wife's murder, Paul is moved by both Rashid's quest to reconnect with his father and Auggie's discovery that a woman who might be his daughter is about to give birth.

More about it

What happens

Five chapters in the story of how a smoke shop brought five strangers together.

What sets it apart

Auggie’s Christmas story scene. Smoke is full of unforgettable little grace notes, and it gives each member of its brilliant ensemble their moment to shine, but Keitel’s is the one you finish the movie thinking about — and not just because it happens near the end credits. Across 12 minutes, Keitel’s character shares a bittersweet anecdote with Hurt’s Paul, who’s looking for inspiration for an impending writing assignment. Like us, Holender’s camera can’t resist the mesmeric pull of the actor: we slowly zoom in on his face as he enthralls us with his naturalistically delivered monologue, ending up with a frame filled with just his moving lips. It’s a testament to Keitel’s utterly masterful storytelling ability that 12 minutes don’t feel like enough — you want the moment to go on and on.

TL;DR

The movie equivalent of a fine Cuban cigar.

Awards

Berlin

1 win

Won: Jury Prize

SAG Awards

1 nomination

Nominated: Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Supporting Role

Spirit Awards

1 win, 1 nomination

Won: Best First ScreenplayNominated: Best Supporting Male

Nat. Board of Review

1 win

Won: Top Ten Films

César Awards

1 nomination

Nominated: Best Foreign Film

Comments

Add your review

Your email address will not be published.*

About the author

Farah Cheded

Farah Cheded

Farah Cheded is a UK-based curator at A Good Movie to Watch and a Rotten Tomatoes-approved freelance critic whose work has been published at outlets including The Playlist, Paste Magazine, and Film School Rejects. She lives in fear of the day she runs out of 'Columbo' episodes to watch.