To Be and To Have (2002) | agoodmovietowatch

100% human-curated. No AI, no algorithms.

To Be and To Have 9.0 2002 Movie

To Be and To Have

Dir. Nicolas Philibert · France · French

A deeply charming school-set documentary that overflows with all the warmth and wonder of its subjects

Our take by Farah Cheded

This gorgeous documentary opens on the snowy fields of its rural French setting, but the single classroom it spends much of its time in couldn’t be warmer or more inviting. That comforting atmosphere — which the film imbibes, too — is all thanks to the kindness and patience of Monsieur Lopez, the man responsible for the education of all of the village’s kids (up to age 11). Chronicling the final year of his career before retirement, this doc shares the instinctive empathy its chief subject has for his pupils and, accordingly, shoots them quite simply, trusting that the high drama of their little lives is enough to sustain the film.

And it is: from the cheeky antics of happy-go-lucky four-year-old Jojo to the crippling anxiety of older kids grappling with parental illness and the terrifying move to middle school, we’re plunged deep into a full spectrum of raw emotion. Inspiringly, Monsieur Lopez doesn’t just teach the kids maths and spelling — he also gently coaches them in off-syllabus skills, like talking about feelings and reconciling differences (even turning a fraught relationship between two boys into loyal friendship by the end of the year). There’s so much to learn from him and his perpetually wonderstruck kids here.

What happens

The documentary's title translates as "to be and to have", the two auxiliary verbs in the French language. It is about a primary school in the commune of Saint-Étienne-sur-Usson, Puy-de-Dôme, France, the population of which is just over 200. The school has one small class of mixed ages (from four to twelve years), with a dedicated teacher, Georges Lopez, who shows patience and respect for the children as we follow their story through a single school year.

What the critics said

Notable Critics

"It demonstrates without overreaching what an actual teacher can do to shape lives."

— Peter Rainer

More about it

What happens

A rollercoaster year in the classroom of Monsieur Lopez, a teacher in rural France.

What sets it apart

Monsieur Lopez is the obvious MVP of To Be and To Have, but little Jojo is a close runner-up. Director Nicolas Philibert gives the pint-sized four-year-old generous screen time, correctly recognizing that the size of his personality demands it. Whether it’s his seemingly endless awe at the fact there exists a number bigger than 1000 (and 1001, 1002, etc., etc.) or his frustration as he tries to work a photocopier ten times his size, Jojo is a constant scene-stealer, and could single-handedly convert even the most cold-hearted viewer into an ardent fan of this doc.

TL;DR

Come for the wholesome portrait of an inspiring teacher, stay for a four-year-old losing his cool at a photocopier.

Awards

Cannes

1 nom

Nominated: Official Selection

BAFTA

1 nom

Nominated: Best Film not in the English Language

European Film Awards

1 win

Won: European Documentary

César Awards

1 win · 2 noms

Won: Best EditingNominated: Best DirectorNominated: Best Film

Comments

Add your review

Your email address will not be published.*

About the author

Farah Cheded

Farah Cheded

Farah Cheded is a UK-based curator at A Good Movie to Watch and a Rotten Tomatoes-approved freelance critic whose work has been published at outlets including The Playlist, Paste Magazine, and Film School Rejects. She lives in fear of the day she runs out of 'Columbo' episodes to watch.