Fargo | agoodmovietowatch
Back
Show

Fargo 2023

A gorgeous, dense, and consistently intriguing spin on the Coen Brothers film

Our Take (by Emil Hofileña)

Taking the violence and offbeat comedy of the original movie and adding constantly expanding narratives on top of it, Noah Hawley’s TV adaptation of Fargo arguably becomes an even richer portrait of the dark side of human nature hiding inside modern, polite society. All four complete seasons of the anthology series (with a fifth currently ongoing at the time of this writing) are an exercise in seeing how many dominoes can topple from a series of mismanaged coincidences. The resulting chaos then becomes more of a reflection on the kind of facades these characters would rather maintain for the sake of some semblance of control.

And perhaps with the exception of the show’s ambitious but sluggish fourth season, every Fargo story is dripping in suspense and cinematic polish, with plenty of chilling visuals and intricate music and sound design—not to mention ensemble casts who are almost always at the height of their powers. Each season has at least one stand-out, be it Alison Tolman and Billy Bob Thornton in season one, Carrie Coon and David Thewlis in season three, Ben Whishaw in season four, and practically everybody from season two. These are all actors who understand exactly how to inhabit the world Hawley has deepened, through wry humor and surprising pathos.

Notable Critics

"Noah Hawley's adaptation converts the drollery of the Coen brothers film into a mood much more noirish and grotesque..."

— Doreen St. Felix

"The last half-hour of the 90-minute pilot is the strongest section, because it develops a tone that could be described as Coen-esque, but does so organically, in a way that assures you that it will become its own thing."

— Matt Zoller Seitz

Synopsis

A close-knit anthology series dealing with stories involving malice, violence and murder based in and around Minnesota.

More about it

What happens

An anthology of crime stories set in and around Minnesota, involving ordinary people accidentally becoming involved in clashes between law enforcement and organized crime rings.

What sets it apart

Everyone seems to have their favorite Fargo story, but for my money, the second outing remains one of the best seasons of TV broadcast on an American network. Stylistically bold and narratively complex right from the beginning, its story of a naive hairdresser and her unassuming butcher husband (an incredible Kirsten Dunst and Jesse Plemons, respectively) getting entangled with a crime family (led by Jean Smart) and the local police (Patrick Wilson and Ted Danson) begins with a UFO sighting and a hit-and-run—and snowballs into a sophisticated sage of betrayal, delusions of the American dream, and the yearning for universal harmony.

TL;DR

Never underestimate the amount of death and depravity that can be stuffed into your humble Midwestern city!

Awards

Oscars

2 wins, 5 nominations

Won: Best ActressWon: Best Original ScreenplayNominated: Best CinematographyNominated: Best DirectorNominated: Best EditingNominated: Best PictureNominated: Best Supporting Actor

Cannes

1 win

Won: Best Director

Golden Globes

4 nominations

Nominated: Best Actress: Musical or ComedyNominated: Best DirectorNominated: Best Motion Picture: Musical or ComedyNominated: Best Screenplay

BAFTA

1 win, 5 nominations

Won: Best DirectionNominated: Best CinematographyNominated: Best EditingNominated: Best FilmNominated: Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading RoleNominated: Best Screenplay

Nat. Board of Review

1 nomination

Nominated: Official Selection

Comments

Add your review

Your email address will not be published.*

About the author

Emil Hofileña

Emil Hofileña

Emil Hofileña is a curator at A Good Movie to Watch. He also writes as a theater critic, with work published in Rogue and Out of Print, among others. He’s probably crying over a movie or an episode as we speak.