Let’s get this out of the way: Love Story isn’t an accurate retelling of the marriage between John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bassette, just ask their living relatives about it. However, historical accuracy is not really the point. Much like the other franchises under American Story, Love Story feels more like a portrait of what America used to be– this time, through the closest thing the United States had to a royal marriage. Indulging in the 90s-00s nostalgia, this whirlwind romance takes on familiar themes of celebrity and public scrutiny with all the high-fashion glamor, a semblance of curated taste, and none of today’s social media clout chasing. It helps that Sarah Pidgeon and Paul Anthony Kelly look so good together, with their classic visages and old-school vibes. Love Story doesn’t present something new or true, but the show is nonetheless very watchable.
"It feels as if the show’s portrayals of these figures have been shrouded in a purposeful mystery, which … doesn’t feel like an oversight, but an admirable creative choice that works in the series’ favor."
— Kaiya Shunyata
"Overall, “Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette” is a thoughtful show that centers on the sacrifice of long-term commitment, chemistry, incompatibility and the thunderous chaos of fame."
— Aramide Tinubu
An anthology of sweeping true love stories that captured the world’s attention.
Oscars
1 win, 6 nominations
Golden Globes
4 wins, 3 nominations
DGA
1 nomination
WGA
1 nomination
Nat. Board of Review
1 win
