Their Stories

Their Stories

Two households, unlike in race and class, temporarily share quarters in this unique Brazilian drama

7.2

TV Show

Brazil
Portuguese
Drama
2023
LUCIANA BAPTISTA, MARIA FARKAS
Bia Arantes, Cris Vianna, Emma Araujo

TLDR

This is quite literally a hidden gem. For English-speaking viewers who might be interested in watching, use the Portuguese title “A Historía Delas” instead of its translated English title.

What it's about

After her father gets arrested by the federal police, Isabel and her daughter Rosa move into the home of her former employee Marta and her daughter Jasmim, on a reluctant favor.

The take

A house isn’t just a building– it’s a space where one can be one’s self, where one can have control over one’s space. Of course, houses can differ between social classes, as the rich often hire househelp, while those less fortunate manage their own, or might not even have one. Their Stories draws its drama from this disparity, as the rich Isabel and Rosa lose control of their assets and have to move to the house where working class Marta and Jasmim live. It’s an interesting dynamic, a twisted mix of gratitude and resentment forged between former employer and employee, and all four leads portray this with the nuance and complexity that it requires. A Historía Delas might literally be hard to search on Hulu, but it’s an interesting story, one that feels unique and real enough to follow.

What stands out

Aside from the totally unsearchable English title – even on Hulu itself! – what stands out in Their Stories is the reversal of fortunes between the rich Isabel and the working class Marta. This dual-sided peripeteia isn’t something usually used nowadays, less so in Brazilian dramas, but it’s excellently used here to discuss the clash between race and class divides in Brazil’s multiethnic society. Neither side is demonized in the story, even if there’s resentment on both sides, especially as the moms tend to hold a better relationship with each other’s daughters, with Marta having actually cared for Rosa as her nanny, and Jasmim having a tenuous relationship with her mom, as she feels that Marta’s accommodating their guests too much. The drama in the show never feels contrived, and it’s refreshing to see a careful and nuanced approach to this dynamic in A Historía Delas.

Comments

Add a comment

UP NEXT 

UP NEXT 

UP NEXT 

Ethos

A level of attention to aesthetics usually reserved for the most elaborate films, mixed with a complex and relevant story, make this series from Turkey unmatched in its quality

9.9

Occupied

Norway's most expensive show ever is a timely thrill ride with a grim geopolitical premise.

8.7

Unorthodox

A well-acted fact-based thriller about untangling the grip of a close-knit community

8.5

Escape at Dannemora

Based on a true prison escape story, this slow-burn suspense thriller features once-in-a-lifetime performances by a star-studded cast

9.3

Wild Wild Country

Almost too outrageous to be true – this captivating true crime docuseries tells the unlikely story of an Indian cult in America

9.8

The Good Fight

Like Suits or The Good Wife, but sharper

9.1

Unbelievable

Critics lauded the angle and feminist edge of this grim true crime miniseries.

8.8

Sex Education

Already a future classic, Sex Education is an explicit but endlessly charming teen comedy that will also teach adults a thing or two.

8.9

Patriot

This unique anti-spy drama is one of Amazon Prime's hidden gems

9.0

To the Lake

A Russian thriller about a deadlier pandemic where society goes violent

7.3

Curated by humans, not algorithms.

agmtw logo

© 2024 agoodmovietowatch, all rights reserved.