The Proposition (2005) | agoodmovietowatch
The Proposition 7.3 2005 Movie

The Proposition

Dir. John Hillcoat · Australia, United Kingdom · English

The line between good and evil blurs in this dusty, gritty Outback Western

Our take by Isabella Endrinal

The Western had its heyday in the 60s, but the decades have proven that there’s still stories from the deserts that we haven’t heard yet, and gems that twist the genre on its head. The Proposition is a unique Western, being from the East, in Australia where the Brits have started to form colonies. As the British Empire builds society, and the police start to enforce the King’s justice, writer Nick Cave and director John Hillcoat crafts a bloody tale, where promises between men are betrayed for the State, where vengeance can only be met through brutality, and where the line between civility and savagery is drawn and moved by the will of an angry majority. The Proposition is quite violent, but it’s performed well, scored by a moody, moving soundtrack, and it surprisingly contemplates Australia’s bloody past.

What happens

In 1880s Australia, a lawman offers renegade Charlie Burns a difficult choice. In order to save his younger brother from the gallows, Charlie must hunt down and kill his older brother, who is wanted for rape and murder. Venturing into one of the Outback's most inhospitable regions, Charlie faces a terrible moral dilemma that can end only in violence.

What the critics said

Notable Critics

"Directed by John Hillcoat, it shows humanity striving for a New Testament way of life with a Cain-and-Abel drama on the doorstep."

— Anthony Lane

"Hillcoat and Cave have here found their most fertile ground yet for allegory-rich examinations of life and death in remote, pressure-cooker environments."

— Richard Kuipers

More about it

What happens

Australia, 1880s. Captain Morris Stanley offers gang member Charlie Burns a choice between two brothers: To save his younger brother Mikey from the gallows, Charlie must hunt down his older brother Arthur, wanted for rape and murder, leading him to journey through the inhospitable Outback.

What sets it apart

The landscapes are so beautiful, but the performances are so violent… The contrast makes the scenes both so hard to watch yet so hard to look away from.

TL;DR

No wonder this is Guy Pearce's favorite film he's done.

Awards

Venice

1 win

Won: Gucci Prize

Berlin

1 nom

Nominated: Official Selection

Comments

Add your review

Your email address will not be published.*

About the author

Isabella Endrinal

Isabella Endrinal

Isabella Endrinal is a curator at A Good Movie to Watch. She's now free from the corporate night shift. Previous articles have been published in outlets such as NANG Magazine. She's currently catching up on some classic films… if she isn't coping with the fact that the Haikyu anime will end soon.